Exabis Library

1. To understand the objectives and necessity of head to head trials of new targeted therapies against active comparators in IBD

2. To understand the types of head to head trials in IBD

3. To follow the details of completed head to head trials in IBD and their conclusions

4. To interpret recently completed head to head trials in IBD 

T helper 17 (Th17) cells play an important role in barrier protection in the gastrointestinal tract but are also key pathological drivers of Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD). Although a number of transcription factors governing Th17 differentiation have been identified, the intracellular signalling pathways regulating Th17 differentiation are poorly understood. Hedgehog (Hh) signalling controls cell-fate choices in numerous tissue compartments and is targetable by highly selective, clinically-approved small molecule inhibitors. However the role of Hh signalling in Th17 differentiation and effector function is unstudied.

We generated two conditional knockout mouse models targeting Hh signalling components Smo and Ihh to study Th17 differentiation in vitro by flow cytometry and gene expression analysis. For in vivo studies, T cell adoptive transfer colitis was performed using donor Ihh knockout T cells or heterozygote controls. Histological analysis, mouse weight, colon length/weight measurements, and flow cytometric analysis was performed. We supplement this with the use of two small-molecule Smo antagonists for in vitro and in vivo studies of Th17 function. To underscore the translational relevance of our findings, we conducted bioinformatic analyses of published gene expression datasets of human rectal biopsies from two large independent cohorts of Ulcerative Colitis patients and healthy controls.

We find that intracellular Hh signalling, independently of extracellular Hh ligands, selectively drives differentiation and effector function of Th17 cells but not of other T helper cell lineages. We demonstrate in vivo that inhibition of the Hh pathway with either the clinically-approved small molecule inhibitor vismodegib or genetic ablation of Ihh in CD4⁺ T cells results in a significant decrease in histological and clinical readouts of disease severity as well as a significant reduction in IL-17a+ Th17 cells. Our bioinformatic analyses show that Hh component expression levels are upregulated in human Ulcerative Colitis patient samples and are closely correlated with expression of Th17 markers. Mechanistically we show that the T-cell-intrinsic Indian Hedgehog (Ihh) ligand signals via the signal transducer Smoothened to activate both canonical and non-canonical Hh pathways, through the Gli3 transcription factor and AMPK phosphorylation, respectively.

We uncover Hh signalling as a novel pathway controlling Th17 differentiation and pathogenicity in IBD with Gli3 acting as a newly-identified crucial regulatory transcription factor. Our work paves the way for the use of Hh inhibitors for the treatment of IBD.

The role of histopathology evaluation in Crohn’s disease (CD) is not precisely defined. Due to the heterogeneity of phenotypes, the discontinuity of distribution, and the transmural nature of inflammation, the interpretation of histologic outcomes is complex. To analyze how histology relates to established outcomes in CD, we examined association between histologic and endoscopic disease activity measured by frequently used scores (simple endoscopic score for Crohn’s disease [SES-CD], Robarts histopathology index [RHI], global histological activity score [GHAS]) and the association between histologic or endoscopic severity with inflammatory biomarkers in a cohort of patients with moderate-to-severe CD.

Patients (N=191) who were enrolled in a phase 2 randomized clinical trial (NCT02891226) in patients with moderate-to-severe CD were assessed at baseline (BL) for endoscopic disease location and severity as measured by SES-CD. Biopsies were obtained during BL endoscopy from the edge of the ulcers and the most inflamed mucosa in terminal ileum and 4 colonic segments (ascending, transverse, descending, rectum; N=10/patient, 2 per location with the more severe score used), and scored by central readers blind to study treatment, timepoint, and response status using RHI and both modified and active GHAS (mGHAS: Q1, 3, 4, 5, 6; aGHAS: Q1, 4, 5, 6; see Fig. 1). Inflammatory biomarkers included fCLP and CRP; log-transformed values are used. Linear correlations between measures were determined using Pearson correlation coefficients (PCC) as exploratory analyses. Nominal p values are presented.

SES-CD correlated well with all 3 histologic measures examined (Fig. 1). While both fCLP and CRP correlated more closely with endoscopy than with histologic measures, fCLP had higher correlation with each histologic measure than CRP (Fig. 2). 64% of patients had the same disease location at BL when measured by endoscopy or histology. Patients with endoscopic colonic disease displayed histologic ileal involvement in up to 20% of cases, while 13% of patients with endoscopic ileal disease demonstrated histologic colonic involvement (Table 1).

Although histologic disease activity in CD, as determined by 3 different measures, correlates well with endoscopic assessment of disease, histologic involvement provides complementary information on disease distribution and extension. Further analyses are required to understand the additive role of mucosal histology in CD.

Differential  diagnosis of IBD and chronic colitis could be challenging. In this presentation the histological features of chronicity in IBD will be resumed  and differential diagnosis pointed out.

Educational objectives:
- understand the main features of chronicity of IBD
- compare these features with the main differential diagnosis.